
http://www.ng.mil/resources/photo_gallery/heritage/images/lawsunion.jpg
The Whiskey Rebellion, like the Shays' Rebellion was about taxes, and what the people thought was unfair taxation. Shays' Rebellion was under the Articles of Confederation, while the Whiskey Rebellion of 1794 was under the new federal government. It was a test of the power and effectiveness of the new government.
Although he could have left the problem in the hands of Pennsylvania, George Washington decided to take matters into his own hand- and therefore involving the federal government. Marching to stop the rebellion with 15,000 militiamen, the rebellion was quickly ended. The federal government proved to be very effective.
The Shays' Rebellion was also put down by militiamen, but of the state, not the federal army. However, it was not nearly as effective as Washington's threat, which displayed the organization, power and involvement of the new government. Like Jefferson said,"I hold it, that a little rebellion, now and then, is a good thing." This proved true not only for Shays' Rebellion forcing the government to modify its current state, but also created a chance for the new federal government to prove itself. Is rebellion inevitable for a new and developing nation- even after many rebellions and new start?
Rebellions seem to be an effective way of bring attention to a cause, but there are other ways of making one's opinions understood by others without an uprising. However, those ways can only be taken advantage of if receipted well by a reasonable government. With Shays' Rebellion, there was no one to go to. With the Whiskey Rebellion, the government was still not ready to listen and had not made it easy for the people express their ideas in a way that would be accepted and taken into consideration. An uprising seemed to be the only option. Yet seeing how quickly the national government put down the rebellion, it showed the people that that practice was no longer effective or accepted. New ways of communication from the people to the government had to be made.